Why couldn't whatever the centaurs did be perfectly normal for centaurs? In any case, Umbridge, being a coward, could simply have been terrorized by the centaurs. She doesn't seem to have been seriously physically injured, so maybe they just kept threatening her for several hours. Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site the association bonus does not count.
Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead? Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Home Questions Tags Users Unanswered. What happened to Umbridge when she was carried into the forest by the centaurs? Ask Question. Asked 7 years, 5 months ago. Active 8 months ago. Viewed 52k times. Whatever it was, she was clearly very shaken by the ordeal. Is cracked. I always hoped the centaurs handed Umbridge a shovel and made her follow the parade.
Although I definitely wouldn't call Cracked "canon", I do believe they actually cite an interview with JKR where she at least implies they did some The point they make is JKR would have had to have know about that aspect of centaur lore. They go on to say that Hermione would have definitely known about it. Things that might have happened to her. Rowling People in this discussion seem to think that what happened to her was sexual , because of the mythology behind Centaurs. My thoughts on the cracked article Non-canon They didn't mention any canon references to Centaurs acting like this in any other HP literature.
Madam Pompfrey says she's just in shock,' whispered Hermione. SQB Pobrecita Pobrecita 6, 4 4 gold badges 34 34 silver badges 74 74 bronze badges. But, why would Dumbledore rescue her at all?
Wouldn't Umbridge being one of Hogwarts' employees combined with Dumbledore's personality explain this adequately? Wikia is not a credible source.
Taken by the Centaurs – eriserato
Note that the "unscathed" remark is coming from Harry, not Madame Pomfrey. If she's wearing something with long sleeves, then things like bruises on her arms wouldn't be visible. Certainly, signs of violent sexual activity wouldn't be visible to passing visitors.
Madame Pomfrey might have declined to get into specifics with two underage students when she said Umbridge was just in shock. Nonsuch Ned Nonsuch Ned 6 6 silver badges 13 13 bronze badges. Ward Ward 8, 3 3 gold badges 46 46 silver badges 61 61 bronze badges. Either way, we have to look at their actions on a human through the eyes and judgements of humans, no? I imagine that they would have at least imprisoned her within some kind of crude cage after they did whatever they did to her. I mean, she was in there for hours before Dumbledore too-kindly rescued her.
My random speculation counts for naught but since the question is all about guesswork : -- Being familiar with centaur myths when I read the book I figured that the same would be true with these centaurs: rape, namely.
- Taken by the Centaurs.
- Centaur (small Solar System body) - Wikipedia.
- Shoeless Joe?
- The Trusting Game (Mills & Boon Modern);
- The Zero Gate.
- Veloxian Centaurs | Character Profile | Depths of Erendorn.
However, the centaur centaurs? That, however, doesn't stop them expressing a willingness to do so and could easily terrify her with such talk: she could end up traumatised without being touched. As far as I know the donkey was not punished, so not only did you read about such a universe, you live in one! Cracked wasn't the first people to suggest this. The first instance of this idea that I recall came from dollymix.
By the looks of it they roughed her up, but I wouldn't think they would harm her. Even though the centaurs are rather brazen creatures, I wouldn't imagine they're that bad even though she had it coming.
And no, Rowling has never discussed what happened, so it is up to our imagination. Nata2ha Mayan2 Nata2ha Mayan2 1 1 gold badge 3 3 silver badges 7 7 bronze badges.
Taken by the Centaurs Series
Any reasons why you don't think they wouldn't harm her? They roughed up Firenze and it sounds like they would have killed him if Dumbledore wouldn't have intervened. They're pretty clear in the books that they aren't the types to be messed with. In my opinion, it was understood they were quite dangerous.
- Inside the Forbidden Forest - Pottermore.
- Related Articles;
- JT & the Holy Trinity;
- Centauriad #1: Daughter of the Centaurs.
Dason I think it's because even though they are violent, they aren't stupid. There's alot more wizards there it seems than centuars, so killing her would've probably pissed off the Ministry of Magic. Nata2haMayan2 Did anybody from the ministry even know she was in the forest? I doubt it would've ever come out that the centaurs did it if they just killed her and left her somewhere deep in the forest. Featured on Meta. Unicorn Meta Zoo 9: How do we handle problem users? Favorite Questions and answers from third quarter of A note on the shape of the centaur is necessary, since they are not always depicted in the form with which we are most familiar.
Our earliest references involve no real description at all. They were very brave men, and they did battle with the very brave mountain-dwelling [centaurs] and destroyed them terribly. These are not the footprints of a man or woman, or of hoary wolves or bears or lions, nor do I think these are from a shaggy centaur, whoever makes such monstrous footprints with swift feet.
The best early evidence from which we can draw any real conclusions comes from material art, which represents some centaurs with human feet and genitals in the front. It has been suggested that these were late models, which represent evolutions of a centaur form that was not hippomorphic at all. Thus it remains reasonable to look to centaurs for evidence of Greek attitudes toward horses. As in the case of the IE horse the association between centaurs and sexuality is very common, but in the case of the centaurs that sex is almost always violent. Once Cypris [Aphrodite] ran like the winds fleeing the pursuit of her amorous father, so that she might not see an unlawful fatherly bedmate, and her father Zeus gave up his pursuit of the union, leaving untouched the swifter, unattainable, and unwilling Aphrodite.
Instead of the bed of Aphrodite, he ejaculated on the earth, pouring forth the love-shower of child-producing plows. The earth received the marital dew of the son of Cronos and hurled forth the strange horned race. The myth of the wedding of Peirithoos is another well-documented example of the violent sexual nature of centaur mythology. This wedding is said to have led to the famous battle of the Lapiths and Centaurs, which is frequently depicted in literature and which is an important enough artistic motif to appear on the Parthenon, the Hephaisteion, and the temple to Zeus at Olympia.
Join the Conversation
At this wedding the centaur Eurytion attempted to rape the bride, and the other centaurs followed by attempting to rape the other women and boys in attendance. Zeus was in disbelief, so tested Ixion by fashioning an eidolon, or copy, of Hera, like that fashioned of Helen, and Ixion did indeed have sex with it. From this union was born a man named Kentauros, who had sex with the mares around Mount Pelion, and from them the race of the centaurs was born. Since chariot wheels spin due to the force of horses this form of punishment is ironic.
Unlike Greek mythological horses, however, the centaur is almost always male, as confirmed by a story about Zeuxis told by Lucian. I want to give you an example from a painter. Zeuxis, that most excellent of painters, did not depict popular or common themes heroes, gods, or wars, for example but always endeavored to create novelty, and when he created something new and unusual he demonstrated the precision of his skill.
Among his daring works, this Zeuxis created a female centaur, one who, moreover, nursed twin centaur children, babies. It is useful to dwell for a moment on the anomalous centaur, Chiron, the legendary trainer of Achilles, about whom there is no story of violent sex. Hesiod says that he is the child of Phillyra, [ 10 ] and other sources add that he is the child of Cronos who mated with this Phillyra, a daughter of Oceanos, while he had taken the form of horse.
Although he represents a particularly dangerous and uncontrollable expression of the forces discussed throughout this work, the centaur does, in a way, exhibit the same thematic nexus of hippomorphism, sex, and power that was seen in the hero. It is in this twisted manifestation of the very elements of heroic identity, expressed hippologically, that the centaur achieves his identity, a reflection of the hero that is nevertheless grotesquely anti-heroic.
Centaurs have occasionally been linked to the Indian gandharvas , celestial beings who have partially animalistic forms. The similarities in the names makes this connection tempting, but an etymological link is simply not present.